Middle Class Is Wiped Out! - Arthur Hayes’ Warning On Money, Bitcoin, War, China & Economic Collapse
hozhK-NKkQo • 2024-03-26
Transcript preview
Open
Kind: captions Language: en Bitcoin is worthless if you do nothing with it if no one trades a bit another Bitcoin ever again it falls to zero hold on that's a very big statement there's chaos in the universe it's always increasing everyone's going to go to war at some point so everyone's beefing up on defense the incentives you create by allowing the government to steal is so wrong that we're going to create an entirely new system we've accomplished nothing we have not done what Bitcoin is there to do and therefore we will be rewarded with zero do you think that we are in a truly once in a-lifetime moment that um people should stop pay attention figure out what their crypto strategy is absolutely we are at the culmination of the post World War II period we've we've we've had four generations since then so all the people who fought in the War pretty much dead so we've lost that that knowledge that reticence to ever do something stupid and terrible like a total World War ever again now we have people around the world who are celebrating these leaders who are bombing indiscriminate civilians because it you know solves their particular issue whatever that is because we don't have this institutional knowledge so everyone else is dead who would participated in World War II so and we also have a a situation where you know the United States did very well out of War War II and created a whole global system that to preserve their hegemony and now that's coming undone uh and you know when top dog is getting challenged by the dogs at the bottom there's always conflict and so we're at that point in time we have no institutional memory of how bad war is and we have a preeminent power that's being challenged by others who was going to resort to violence to preserve their position I think we are at this situation that has happened in the past many times empires have come and gone but now we have for the first time in human history a an ability to save in a currency Bitcoin and the cryptocurrency situation in general that is globally owned by everyone and so the people own a new type of money it's people around the world can still sell their Fiat whatever and buy Bitcoin it's not blocked or banned in most places yet and so you're able to move wealth between this analog system that we've had for thousands of years into a new way of socially creating Financial wealth the financial system a new type of money this sort of this sort of situation is never going to happen again because we have all these Fiat assets that are being depreciated and everyone knows it's happening and now we have this little small door called Bitcoin and people are starting to go through the small door and that's why the Bitcoin price is up I don't know 50% or 60% this year already as now we have the institutional investors saying yeah I understand this game is rigged I helped rig the game now I have a product where I can can get out of this mess that I created get me the [ __ ] out of government bonds I want some of this Bitcoin too so now everyone's competing to get in this little door and that's why the price is going up so this is a once in a-lifetime Opportunity we have a system reset and we have a way to preserve wealth in the old system and bring it into the new system and that's what crypto is all right that's powerful so if we think of crypto as the arc that we can all get on before the rain comes uh the catch is that you've got all kinds of different cryptocurrencies all kinds of different thesis about which one we should be getting into um what's your take how do you break down the world of crypto so Bitcoin is the reserve currency if you will of crypto it's the ultrasound money it's it's crypto money it's and it's proven that's that's what it cares about the community of Bitcoin cares about security and um the immutability of the Bitcoin blockchain and it wants to make it the soundest crypto money so if you're thinking about okay I don't know anything else about crypto but I kind of believe in this whole inflation and changing Global relations story than just buy Bitcoin right it's got the largest market cap um it's very conservative with the types of things that are added to the the network because everyone wants to make sure that Bitcoin is always the hardest money so the experimentation is much lower on bitcoin than other uh other networks um next you go to well okay can we build a new Financial system within crypto that's decentralized Finance defi um and ethereum in my in my worldview is the the best decentralized computer that has been built uh thus far and so if you think okay I think we need a new Financial system that's based on these crypto know crypto assets that's decentralized that's transparent blah blah blah then ethereum uh is where it's at now once you get past those two things I'd say most other things in than crypto are either some sort of application that rides on top of ethereum or a decentralized like computer another blockchain trying to disrupt either being the best money or the best decentralized computer and then you sort of have to get into the Weeds on understanding what it is these Protocols are are trying to do so for those who just want to like close their eyes and buy something that's crypto safe not saying that's you know there's no risk here I would say Bitcoin and ethereum are where you should start your journey and once you say okay maybe there's some things I think these protocols could do better or I've been hearing some things about these exciting new very smart people building something then you start going down the rabbit hole of of other coins that do other things and obviously have more risk because they're experimenting more what do you advise people around volatility I think one of the things that draws people to crypto specifically is is the volatility I'm actually very curious to see what happens to um cultural energy around crypto once it's the the tried and true thing volatility is your friend the reason why you're even thinking about crypto is because the price went up a lot and you heard about it so you want volatility the entire trafi traditional government apparatus is trying to do something unnatural which is remove volatility from the system entropy is always is increasing it is unnatural to try to suppress volatility think about it like your lawn if you have one at your house right entropy says the grass keeps growing because that's what the grass does what do you try to do you spend energy to cut the grass because you want it to look a certain way a certain nonvolatile Pleasant way but it's unnatural if you don't have the energy to cut the grass the Grass Grows and the grass will grow long after you're gone because you can only do this so long and that's the same thing governments and central banks and banking systems are doing they're trying to squash volatility we don't want volatility and they're trying to convince you that it's safe but there is no such thing as safe there's chaos in the universe it's always increasing they're doing the unnatural Thing by trying to remove it and then at certain points they can't do it anymore and then there's an explosion somewhere whether it's a war whether it's a financial crisis so embrace the volatility this is the nature of the universe and that's why Bitcoin in crypto is a good thing because there is none of this manipulation it goes up it goes down but it's a true reflection of what the universe is so I think volatility is a good thing obviously that means if you use leverage be very judicious about it if you're a leverage if leverage trading is your thing that better be your full-time job like you better eat breathe and sleep the thing that you're trading because that's the only way that you're going to survive thinking that you're going to get home from work put on some highly leveraged crypto trade and just trade for a few hours and then go to sleep you will lose all your money okay volatility as a good thing do you think that crypto will lose some of its um its potency its cultural energy when the volatility begins dying down or will like in a given cycle the way that this traditionally goes is uh you've got Bitcoin which has massive volatility but is less Vol volatile than some of the what people lovingly call shitcoins um so people tend to go down the curve so they'll start with Bitcoin they'll ride that up as that begins to stabilize and chop sideways then they're going to go to the next volatile if that crashes or whatever they go to the next the next the next constantly chasing volatility um will that forever be people will just keep introducing new and highly volatile things or will it become more like gold where it's it's a far more stable entity well Bitcoin as you law of large numbers the larger it gets the less volatile it becomes um and as you mentioned right for people who are saying I want to make big gains in a short period of time Bitcoin might not do it for them they say well I need the next new new new thing and so they start trading whatever the new shiny Bobble is that's being sold out there in in crypto there's nothing wrong with that just recognize what you're trying to do if you're saying I want to save in a ultrasound money then yes so volatility is not a good or bad thing for Bitcoin it's it will go down over time as the asset class gets bigger if you're saying I need the volatility I'm a professional Trader this is what I'm here for then there will always be a new thing to trade because the great thing about crypto is it's this the only free market left where humans are expressing themselves and whatever is we think is valuable there's no manipulating force with you know an unlimited bag of fiat currency that's telling us what is a good and or bad investment and so there will always be volatile things within the crypto ecosystem so long as there's human beings Trading and I guess we'll have the machines too soon these AI operators uh in the ecosystem it's really interesting so I want to get to the essence of um what crypto is I want to get to the essence of What markets are why people play them so I I really want to be the contribution that I make to um I mean anything that I do quite frankly is helping people get to the essence of it to think from first principles to build a thesis uh even though ultimately I think that only the simple spreads I do want people to be able to understand the the nature of this do do you see markets as gambling like are they gambling at their very nature I'd move it even more fundamental we are gamblers everyone all the time constantly because we don't know what the future holds um so let's take an example and I wrote this in a previous essay so imagine you're going there's a building you walk out the building you can either take the stairs or take an elevator um so the stair taking the stairs using your own feet walking up is safer than the mechanical thing which is an elevator but walking up the stairs takes more energy than riding up the elevator so what do you do well your brain you know whether you're conscious of it or not is constantly evaluating the probability that if I do one of these things will there will there be harm that comes to me and is the probability of that harm outweighed by the gain whether it's time or energy by using one or the other modes of transportation and so you're gambling you don't know what do you know if this elevator is going to break down and fall 30 flights in an instant no but you believe that there's been a um credible engineer that's designed this piece of technology that there's a government building codes that govern how it's been installed and how it's been made so the risk of me taking this elevator even though I don't know if it's going to fail when I get on it is very very low therefore I will take the elevator because it's faster and less energy spent than walking up the stairs to the top of the building right so we gamble all day every day because the future is unknown so for people that say that oh markets are bad because it's gambling no your whole life is a gamble you do not know what's going to happen one moment to the next you are constantly assigning a probability to the Future and that's what the market is the market is for a particular thing what does the crowd say the probability of the future of this company building this product making this money or this asset being worth whatever it's worth in the future what do the crowd think that's what the market is telling us and the market gives us great signals as to what the crowd actually thinks because we're putting our money on the line and what is money money is Just Energy and our time in an abstracted form that's why money is the most important thing in any society because if you degrade the value of money you degrade someone's time and their effort and their energy and it it's you know it's a front to human dignity if you degrade the value of the money that they earn by doing work to you know earn a living pay for food blah blah blah right so markets are gambling but your entire existence is a gamble as well so I don't think there's a problem with that okay this is uh really interesting and it goes back to what I was talking about with um the ability to save from where I'm sitting feels like it should be a human right uh so okay let me just go back and recap what you said money is energy and time in an abstracted form so uh you go to work and some you do a thing that the world says that they value which is why somebody's willing to pay you for that because they're able to create a thing that they sell to somebody so you spend energy and time creating a thing that people want to buy now what that allows you to do is Pro of work so you have this unit of money that you've exchanged for your labor now when you are putting that into a system where they can socialize losses so H this is it drives me crazy how complicated this all is but let me just walk everybody through what ends up happening in the current Keynesian economic model that we have which uh I'll give a brief summation of Keynesian economic if you see that I've gone wrong in any way please jump in uh Keynesian economics is basically hey uh the market left to its natural devices is going to swing wildly there are going to be massive upsides there are going to be massive downsides and if you if you get to one of the moments where the economy is not able to progress forward part of the reason it may not be progressing forward and this is the break from the classical model is that people are just poor and and so if you stimulate money into the system now you can get the economy moving again and so you flatten the curves both on the upside and the downside so you're squeezing the volatility by um going back to your mowing the lawn analogy you're injecting energy into the system the the government is putting this new money which they're making up out of thin air into the system in order to get people feeling like they have money again it is very much a a man-made manipulation of the system but this is essentially what we've been doing since the Great Depression so uh canes comes up with this idea in the Great Depression and he realizes hey wait a second there are people willing to work there are factories here that are not at capacity there are even people willing to buy and if they just had money then the economy would start moving again so hey make up money okay sounds amazing until you put it together with what you just said and the fact that this is socializing losses so all right something bad happens 1929 we have an economic collapse um people got into a bubble we just got into a bad situation for a whole host of reasons I won't go into it right now but anyway bad thing happens the government then says oh I'm going to print more money which is now taking that loss and spreading it across everybody that's what happens when you're printing money because there's no new Goods put into the system that anybody wants there's no new labor that has gone into the system there's only the artifact what should be the artifact of somebody's time and energy but it's not it's just made up and so that ends up diluting across everybody so you have individual losses with that are spread across everybody to the benefit of only people that hold assets so now you get this massive bifurcation so I'm very worried about the hollowing of the middle class and going back to what exactly creates this as far as I can tell is this it is this moment right here where you are socializing losses across everybody so the poor the middle class and the wealthy are all going to have their buying power reduced but only people that have assets are going to get wealthier and so what's crazy is if you look at the moment that we're living in right now you have a growth in the upper class so if you break lower middle upper you've growth in the upper and you have growth in the lower and only the middle class is going down now at first I was like well that's kind of exciting you actually have more people going into the upper class than you have going into low lower class amazing right but as you Hollow that out you get just literal Division and warfare within a country all of that makes sense based on what you just said which is that money is your time and energy in an abstract form and it is an affront to human dignity when you begin messing with that system yes now laying all that out this this is why I am really unnerved by the moment that we're living in now and we'll I'll try to tie this all back to um crypto as the potential Arc that we're all going to get on as the the rain continues to fall but just today uh one of my employees came up to me and was like I'm finally seeing the data that backs up what I feel which is I just cannot get she didn't say American Dream but that was the punchline I can't afford to buy a house I see other people making huge amounts of money and I'm not I'm not able to get ahead and on paper it seems like I'm making enough money but I just don't feel like I'm getting anywhere and so she isn't positive about the moment that she's in nor is she optimistic about the future because they're there are these cues that people look to buying nice things having a nice car having a nice house feeling like you can afford children feeling like when you retire it's going to be travel and fancy restaurants and it isn't going to be me working until I'm 85 and you know super unhappy and so when you take that you take the anger you take the frustration you take the GameStop of it all again people yoloing in people I don't want to say following sort of culty ideas but like an idea will gain momentum and they just get on board with that momentum versus doing what you said get your spending under control figure out your risk appetite deploy that into um an asset class that you believe is matches your risk appetite and is going to go somewhere okay so there's been a demoralization of people they don't understand what it is but it's not to be too harsh but it's it's Keynesian economics it's the manipulation of the currency it's the massive inflation to deal with debt okay if all of that is true then it certainly explains means this Great Migration from trafi over into crypto does all of that feel right or do you feel like I'm being unfair to the current economic situation to Keynesian economics maybe I don't understand it I mean the only wrinkle that I would say is that if the government is able to borrow money and build things of real economic value like okay in the 19 1950s Eisenhower did the in the United States President US President Eisenhower did the highway act right and the US built however many millions of kilometers of roads which lowered the cost of Transportation you know had all this you basically had the explosion of mass Market stuff because you could ship things from coast to coast blah blah blah in China you had building of uh hydroelectric dams okay there was some environmental cost but it brought Elric electricity to the countryside and so these are only projects that governments can can do because they have the ability to tax uh and spend on a on a aggregate level so I say the only caveat is if you're able as a government to build these types of things that have a rate of return greater than the debt the implicit debt cost that you're wasting on the economy then those are good things to do the problem is that there there's there's a finite of projects like that uh the society that you're building these things in can only accept so much of this infrastructure spending the problem is that governments don't know when to stop they don't know they think everything's going to be like the highway act in the 1950s in the United States or building free gorgees Dam in China versus where it is today which is the building they're building a lot of stuff that has no value because it'll never earn back its its return if you want to be able to enjoy a glass of wine with dinner or a cold one after a long day but you don't want to take away from your ability to focus and be productive the next day you got to check out zbiotics zbiotics pre-color drink is the world's first genetically engineered probiotic it was invented by PhD scientist to tackle rough mornings after drinking here's how it works when you drink alcohol gets converted into a toxic byproduct in the gut it's this byproduct not dehydration that's to blame for your rough next day zbiotics produces an enzyme to break this byproduct down just remember to make zbiotics your first drink of the night drink responsibly and you'll feel your best tomorrow go to zbiotics docomo to get 15% off your first order when you use impact at checkout zbiotics is back with a 100% money back guarantee so if you're unsatisfied for any reason they'll refund your money no questions asked remember to head to zbiotics docomo the code impact at checkout for 15% off what are we building today well I mean I'm saying we as a global Society I don't know what politicians in the US are building or China or anywhere I'm just making sort of a obled statement of people I don't know there's Biden doing what's it the inflation reduction act or some sort of act that they're building stuff in all these government subsidies to build things whether it's electrification of the Grid or whatever right there's industrial policies for governments around the world saying we need to build whatever it is we think is valuable as a government sometimes that's rooted in Market signals other time it's just hey I want to give a a backhander to my boy in my uh in my district that's the problem there is a good there is good that can be done doing that but politicians abuse it and we're at the abusive stage of you know the initial gains of building some of these pieces of public infrastructure now we're just doing stupid [ __ ] Ray alio talks a lot about debt cycles and the inevitability of how this just Loops over and over um is all of this inevitable and do you think that the migration to cryptocurrency will be complete and will'll never be back in a system like this again or do you think these systems will coexist so it's definitely not inevitable uh the great example is what's happened down in Argentina so the policy of Argentina is if you've never been it's a beautiful country [ __ ] love it down there I've been skiing there and you know to the the falls and all kind of stuff it's got a massive Coastline it's got aable land great food great wine space for people to live and yet it's mired in poverty and inflation because of political choices of Keynesian taken to you know another level the her onist um sort of political culture down there and the people after I don't know 50 or 60 years of this [ __ ] are finally fed up let's try something different and you have President melee down there who basically campaigned on a promise of I'm going to cut down government services close a bunch of Ministries we're going to balance a budget and he's already balanced a budget I think within the first quarter or two of him being there so we'll see how the economy reacts so the people do have an option they can reject what the elites are telling them oh there's only one way to do this which is print money and do c in economics no there's another way which is you earn them you propose a taxes we the people agree to pay these taxes and you the government do what we told you to do build roads build schools healthc care police force blah blah blah and don't do anything else and this other [ __ ] that that you got that the government has tacked on to their responsibilities um and created all these deficits so there is another option but it requires people to understand you know where's a situation there is there isn't one way to do things there's another way to do things there's a way to run the government like you run your household you make $100 a month you're only able to spend $100 that's it no nobody runs our household like that though there's something about the the culture that we're in right now because if you look at um debt the government operates on a debt businesses are all in debt uh individuals are all in debt we were at 0% interest rates for so long money seem free people just like just took on debt debt debt Deb debt and so it really requires a cultural shift more than anything and I worry that what we're seeing in Argentina is that oh yeah there is a point at which it is so brutally painful that people would rather austerity than continuing to suffer the way they've been suffering but are we anywhere near that point or maybe a better question can we make the change without needing that amount of suffering no because the loss is there the debt has been taken there's been unproductive activity and this is the global thing right Global debt to GDP is I think 360% per the World Bank or something like that and it's been accelerating over the past two decades right so there is an implicit dead weight loss in the system the question is who Bears the loss now that's whatever government is tackling what does everyone government do they push that loss down onto the people themselves VI inflation tax but the loss has to be paid it's not like the Argentinian situation is without losses people are going to lose money in austerity right the question is who loses the money so if it's I don't like austerity because deflation destroys the banking system well in a capitalist Society what happens when a bank goes bankrupt the unsecured creditors take over the bank so put the [ __ ] CEOs of City Bank and JP Morgan and Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley on the [ __ ] Street after 2008 and give the bank to the depositors that's how Bakery law should work it didn't work in that situation they would rather save the managers of the banks than allow the people who are unsecured creditors of the bank take it over and run it how they think it should be run so I think there is we have we being a lot of capitalistic systems and you know even in China they have these sorts of bankruptcy sort of laws it's just that nobody wants to use them because it's going to disenfranchise the elites we have all the tools available to us we've thought about these things we're just unwilling to use them because of who Bears the pain so that's the situation but I think when more people realize the reason why crypto exists it's crypto is valuable because we're unwilling to take these losses if all of a sudden the United States and China and Europe and Japan said we're going to run balanced budgets we're going to cut out 75% of all these government services I would be thinking hard about whether I want to beong crypto at that point and maybe I should be something else because the societal mindset has changed to something more responsible and maybe we're not going to see these massive price gains in crypto because the Fiat debasement part of the equation has ceased okay so if that's a scenario that would cause you to rethink crypto um if all of those governments were hey we're going to be like Argentina we're going to get our stuff together we're going to run a balanced budget how would you respond to that in ter terms of your investment strategy there's obviously going to be some short-term a lot of short-term pain and then you have to see what is bitcoin or crypto worth really fast will you explain why why will there be short-term pain what happens in austerity when we're not printing like right now the US government is so in debt that surely if they were to just balance the budget immediately without printing any more money that holders of government treasuries bonds poof they would be gone yeah who owns the bonds rich people at Banks so that's who suffers if who's making all these you know the the US Treasury spends about a trillion dollars on an annualized basis and interest payments who is getting these interest payments all the [ __ ] I saw at the ski resort who now get five and a half percent on on their um their cash and I great I own these treasury bonds getting five and a half% I've got a good Capital base I'm going to go enjoy the world right it's all the rich people who own these Financial Assets that're Now worth a lot less in a deflationary environment the primary one being government bonds who now the government balance a budget and guess what all that debt we're just gonna gone I they can do it Deb Jubilee it's happened in the past study the Roman Empire and you know Greek Solon and certain people like it's a feature of the society where a leader comes and says this is not a good idea for the rich to be renas on the entire productive capacity of society let's destroy that asset that they have and re- equalize system we forget that this happens but it has happened in the past and so if we did something akin to a debt Jubilee who loses rich people and then at some point if the government does float another bond with a more balanced budget then oh that might be a good investment at a very high rate of return is that better than owning something that has made its gains in Fiat terms I'm not saying that the Bitcoin network is not valuable I separate Bitcoin into Tech technology plus liquidity but if you remove the liquidity piece what's the technology worth I don't know it's worth a lot for sure but removing that liquidity piece from the equation for crypto probably means that it corrects quite substantially and you want to own other types of Assets Now that you know we have the society is decided that we're going to run our public affairs in a different manner all right really fast when you say liquidity are you talking trading volume just the amount of back and forth credit money credit Fe get money in so sorry you said uh Bitcoin is the technology plus liquidity so you mean if nobody's manipulating Fiat and printing printing printing then you take a fundamentally different uh calculation on the value of Bitcoin correct interesting liquidity is one of those words that I've long been like okay I think I know what people mean by this uh but clearly not so when you say liquidity you mean printing yes I mean how much credit money has been created by the government in the banking system and obviously the more Fiat that's around scarce assets finet assets like Bitcoin go up in Fiat terms but that's just a denominator issue it's not anything the value of Bitcoin itself as a network of peer-to-peer decentralized electronic money again that has a value what is that value I think it's very valuable is it I don't know what's the Bitcoin bark down like two trillion or whatever it is is it that so if we removed all the money printing we said you know US dollar the Yen the Yuan you the euro is now sort of very stable currencies not going to go up or down much in terms of their supply do I want to own crypto anymore maybe not at this price maybe there's something else I'd rather own maybe I want to own a power plant in a new productive country where the people feel happy and engaged and want to do productive things maybe I want to own something different so that's that's just the mental you know construct that I'm W under because the system will change we as you said there is this anger we have global conflict spreading up around the world we are not going to be in this Keynesian system in the next 40 or 50 years there will be a different system I don't know what it is it could be that the people all wake up and they say this is not for me we're going to create a more Equitable system or they create something even more [ __ ] up than the one we're in today I don't know but we're just going to change okay uh a couple questions one did Argentina default on their debts they have defaulted multiple times on on their peso dollar like you could probably write a whole university thesis on the history of Argentinian mon monetary policy I mean specifically since melee took office is that part of his strategy like hey debt Jubilee I'm not sure okay I'd be very curious to know that um so okay one possible way for this to end is you have an Argentinian solution uh the country wakes up they realize hey I'm not willing to suffer like this anymore it's a bunch of Rich [ __ ] that are controlling the place we have all these um programs to take care of people but we don't actually have the money and so we've inflated our currency into meaninglessness um this is dumb so let's elect somebody let's take our lumps austerity measures the system's not really working anyway so I imagine to some extent that probably even the wealthy feel like they're on such unstable ground they've probably long ago fled to dollars or something like that anyway if they have the wherewithal to do it uh we this guy he comes in literally with a chainsaw for people that haven't seen the footage it is hilarious uh and he just cuts Cuts Cuts removing entire um portions of the government entire departments uh okay so that's one way to do it um the other way to do it is war why does this why does the debt inflation through money printing why does that lead to this changing dynamic between countries what I I can't mentally track I get it I've seen it I know the data but I don't understand why that happens so when you're printing money you're inducing economic activity that's unnatural so you're producing stuff that you don't you can't sell so what is you know what I'm most wars about it's I have all this excess production I have people that need to work because that's how I stay in power because they have a job and money and whatever they have they're producing all this stuff I need someone to sell it to so if you want to think back to sort of World War I World War II you had the major Colonial Powers each had their own home Market us has you know Central and South America Britain had the Commonwealth um French had the West Indies and sort of parts of Africa and Germany was like Hey I'm a I'm a white Imperial power I deserve I deserve some colonies too rather than going into Africa my Colony should Russia we read what Hitler wrote he's writing about taking the Russian land and creating space for the Russian people for the for the German people that's why he did the dumb thing of attacking Russia during the winter didn't learn his lesson from Napoleon um the Japanese wanted their colon they thought they were a powerful colonizer as well and China specifically Manchuria would be their sphere of colonial projection and their Market would be southeast Asia and as you know the Western Allied Powers challenged that assertion that Germany and Japan could have these Colonial spheres of trading influence because they also had overproduction as well remember coming out of the Great Depression what was the problem too much production nowhere to put it deflation of assets everybody produced too much [ __ ] they needed to sell it somewhere so that was a Genesis of all these of the world wars now what do we have today CH has exhausted its ability to build roads pump a property bubble now they're saying we need to we need to manufacture more stuff well so does America they need to manufacture more stuff so does Europe they need to manufactur more stuff why is Europe all pissed off at China right now because China's the largest Auto exporter in the world surpassing Germany and Japan and they like oh [ __ ] there goes one the one industry where we were kicking ass which was high-end luxury cars and your German and French Vehicles China's beating us at this like hand over hand over foot so everybody producing stuff because they're they're just printing money say go to work make stuff and then it's like okay where do we sell it oh we need to sell our Goods in China Chinese to sell their goods in America well nobody wants to open up their Turf to others because they need to sell stuff not to buy others and so that's why when you print this money and you have all this uneconomic activity happening the drive to sell your goods in other markets is what go is what prepares the road to war oh you're not going to let me sell this particular type of product in you know this country well [ __ ] you we're going to war and I'm going to make sure that you can't sell your stuff into into my turf and that is what we're gearing up towards as all the major economic blocks like okay we need to keep people in their jobs so we're going to print the money they're going to make stuff and now where do we sell it that is very fascinating it certainly is not the only reason that we go to war but that is a very good explan for how when the war's basic cause is economic or when when the debt begins to get out of hand why this ends up marching us towards war that makes a lot of sense do you see a way to unwind this so once it's is it austerity or War are those really the two options or do you see us being able to really in In This Moment use Bitcoin as the um Arc that allows us to avoid either of those catastrophic floods crypto is a way for you to sidestep some of the negative impacts of austerity and austerity is not uniformly distributed in terms of its pain right the people who have the most pain are those who have the most assets because the cash flows are depreciated under austerity there's no more government printing press that's making these things go up in value so if you you know did the thing that what you told to do get on the hamster whe work your ass off and you were able to through hard work build up a Fiat Nest dig and you recognize that this situation is untenable in terms of you know a very small size of the population getting very very wealthy while everyone else is suffering then it behooves you to get out of those Fiat Assets Now previously there wasn't really an easy way to do that but now we have crypto so now if you have Fiat assets that are you know you're saving vehicles or even just the little bit of Fiat money that you're able to save you can now sidestep you can all you can vote for austerity to rebuild your your Society into a more equ Equitable situation but at the same time preserve the little bit of wealth that you've able been able to accumulate in the Fiat system by porting it over to crypto and then you know once things have reset then re-evaluating okay well maybe I am okay with owning a Government Bond that yields 10% if the economy is growing at 5% that's a great return for me I don't need to have this crypto thing maybe it's too volatile for me you maybe I lost a little bit of money trading some particular coin I just want to own some sort of bond in a government that I believe in and respect cool now you know you're getting paid to take that risk versus now you're not getting paid appropriately to take that risk this is a really interesting moment that we live in uh there so history doesn't repeat at Rhymes when you look back I think Ray alio has done such a good job of breaking this down how the the debt cycle loops and how going back 500 years you see the rise and fall of Empires that they roughly last 150ish years um that the sequence of events is such that you have a debt Jubilee I mean I guess it doesn't start with a debt Jubilee but every cycle will will um repeat with that and because you said you um use that as a way to reset to get a more equit situation but the reality is it's only going to be Equitable for a while because once you're dealing in a world where people clip coins which is the OG way of inflating money or the current way which is you literally just you have the FED uh buy assets from the government um you're inflating the money supply you're reducing what you reduce its purchasing power that it is inevitable if you allow that that people will get themselves out of trouble because if people are in pain they're going to freak out they're going to lash out at the government they're going to say I want you to protect me which um it's predictable so you know that people are going to do that so you print money so that you can get reelected so as long as people have to get reelected and one of the ways to get reelected is to print money people are going to do that and so you end up back in this um cycle the fascinating thing is that it it only comes down to any one person's individual lifetime that's all they know and that's all they really care about and so if you can push this off 150 years it you really don't care and it begins to Loop however we are living through a technological Revolution right now that I think is causing a rapid Divergence between the generations which caused them to have very different World Views and so you have this I'll call it a bifurcation but I really think it's it's more of a shattering but just for Simplicity sake I'll say a bifurcation between people who believe in the traditional system because they know it they're used to it it's the devil you know and then people that believe in and the way I think about it is will tomorrow be more digital than today if yes why would I ever think that money wouldn't become digitized and so it just for me as somebody who breaks on the digital side when I looked at crypto I was like oh yeah that it makes sense to me that isn't a a fake asset or whatever people call it magic internet money it's all of money is simply a narrative we all simply decide to agree that oh gold has value because it's scarce the paper money has value because the government says that it does um crypto has money because there's you Bitcoin there's only 21 million of it and that's it and so we all agree that that that's the thing and so so I will be very interested to see as as we March towards adopting cryptocurrency if we really can take that as this off-ramp that will avoid Us ending up in a hot War I just I don't know that governments will allow it to happen what do you think about that how Stern SL violent do you think the government's response is going to be will they control it through ETFs and so same as it ever was or will they say uh we're not going to allow this and and find a way to put Capital controls on it the smart governments will do the ETF route which is allow the traditional trafi people to give you a crypto derivative like a Bitcoin ETF that's the smart way to do it because it's the nonviolent way to do and people think that they've escaped this financial apocalypse but not really they've only just given their money to Black Rock and the time in which they actually want to use Bitcoin for what it's there for which is to centralize money moving it around 247 between whoever they feel like they'll be told no if you want to get out of the ETF you must sell it back for Fiat and then do with your money what you please right you don't own Bitcoin people think they do that's the best way to do it the worst way to do it is to go out and ban it because when you ban something as a government especially in a digital age where people have information at their at their fingertips then they go oh well maybe there's something here why is the government telling me I can't do it maybe I should read a little bit more about this and then they just then they decide oh the government is telling me I shouldn't do it because it's not in their interest then I'm going to do it anyways because you've banned it you've given it air time you've proven the point that all everyone is that everyone on the crypto ecosystem has been saying for years which is the government doesn't have your best interest at heart that's why you're there Banning your economic freedom and then you create the demand for the thing and people will get it anyways right um so if you think about you know the common Narrative of like very you know authoritarian governments in the west like oh China just does whatever they feel like no bitcoin's not even banned in China China bans a lot of things have not banned Bitcoin there are not it's hard to trade it um on sure in China but is not ban did ban it because no Bitcoin is not banned you can own Bitcoin as a Chinese person um they've shut down the it uh you can't mine it and as a exchange the large exchanges no longer offer a Bitcoin REM andb trading pair but you can still trade at OTC and you can can still own it because you know Chinese government's smart they know if I ban something then Chinese people will find it valuable because the government told me I can't do it now that is why if you know the government and the elites want to stay in sort of this financial position the ETF is the best thing that they can do because people believe that they've achieved Financial Freedom when they actually have just handed over fees to the same people who have been [ __ ] them for the past 80 years anyways so that is the smart thing to do but ultimately I think that that attitude is very defeatist if you do believe that a government is a representative body of the will of the people and you just default to saying that it can never change because the Elites in charge want it to stay that way well then nothing will ever change and that's you know that's a lot that's a big detriment you know deriding argument that a lot of people give whether they're a boomer or somebody who's much younger oh Bitcoin is really good I understand like decentralize money sound money you know inflation resistant blah blah blah great but oh but the elites want to let let it happen so I'm not going to own Bitcoin because the people in power are threatened they're not going to let it survive well [ __ ] that buy some Bitcoin tell your friend to buy some Bitcoin shut up from the rooftops create a movement be part of it try to change things so I I think that's a very defeatist attitude and if that's the attitude that everyone wants to have then you deserve to be a [ __ ] death surf what do you really think come on Arthur say something strong come on man stop with this wishy-washy [ __ ] uh yeah that's uh that's very on point I think um I maybe have a little more empathy for uh here here's what I really think I think nuanced ideas are extremely difficult I think the government is extremely powerful staring down the barrel of the government um and deciding that you're going to stand up to them I just do not fault the average person for not being willing to do that so I have deep empathy for people who either a don't understand it don't want to spend their time wrapping their head around it or if they do believe as as I quite frankly do that at some point and honestly the ETFs maybe give me a little bit of comfort because I'm like okay that that gives them a way that and other centralized exchanges like coinbase give them a way to to grab it to to do a thing with it right to feel like they have control and then people that are sort of hey I would at least like to hedge my bets um you know when you think about uh the Second Amendment not to get into this debate but when you think about the idea behind that was hey the government may go tyrannical at some point and you may need to be able to defend yourself that I think people lose sight of that and they think that oh a gun is you know for a home invasion or whatever sure that too yes but like the original intention was the government may turn on you and you need to be able to protect yourself and that America anyway was set up with with that in mind like we're putting all these uh balances of power because governments tend towards tyranny and so you need a way to protect so anyway that having Bitcoin is a bit like the the financial equivalent of the Second Amendment I have the right to maintain my own money I have the right to control it I don't have to I can keep it in a centralized system because good Lord it is so easy to lose your crypto if you are not very careful clicking on an errant link for getting your uh seed phrase I mean just woof uh it does make me tense on that side as well but at at least I know that I have the right it's interesting and I thank you for letting me think through this stuff in real time um but that is why I find myself so drawn to this is okay we have a broken system that is an affront to human dignity using your words uh because of the way that it can be inflated I think that people I think the memes law says that you should just be able to tell somebody save your money and you're going to be fine I know that we don't necessarily agree on that but that feels really true to me that that should just be a right that that no one should be able to take your money and spread it across everybody else I have a feeling that's going to be one of the more controversial things that I say today um just trying to predict the comments but so you start putting that together and you give me the Second Amendment of of financials and now I can take custody of my own money uh I don't th
Resume
Categories