Transcript
feRZv1-OLP0 • Sean Carroll: Time Travel in Many-Worlds
/home/itcorpmy/itcorp.my.id/harry/yt_channel/out/lexfridman/.shards/text-0001.zst#text/0205_feRZv1-OLP0.txt
Kind: captions Language: en how does many-worlds help us understand our particular branch of reality so okay that's fine and good that is everything is splitting a we're just traveling down a single branch of it so how does it help us understand our little unique branch yeah I mean that's a great question but that's the point is that we didn't invent many worlds cuz you thought it was cool to have a whole bunch of worlds right we amended it because we were trying to account for what we observe here in our world and what we observe here in our world are wavefunctions collapsing okay we do have a position of the situation where the electron seems to be spread out but then when we look at it we don't see it spread out we see it located somewhere so what's going on that's the measurement problem of quantum mechanics that's how we have to face up to so many worlds is just a proposed solution to that problem and the answer is nothing special is happening it's still just the Schrodinger equation but you have a wave function - and that's a different answer than would be given in hidden variables or dynamical collapse theories or whatever so the entire point of many worlds is to explain what we observe but it tries to explain what we already have observed right it's not trying to be different from what we've observed because that would be something other than quantum mechanics but you know the idea that there's worlds that we didn't observe they keep branching off it's kind of it is uh you know it's stimulating to the imagination so is it possible to hop from you mentioned the branches are independent yes is it possible to hop from one to the other no it's so physical limit there's a the theory says it's impossible there's already a copy of you in the other world don't worry yes leave them alone no but there's a there's a fear of missing out form oh yes that I feel like immediately start to wonder if that other copy is having more or less fun yeah well the downside of many worlds is that you're missing out on an enormous and that's always what it's gonna be like and I mean there's a certain stage of acceptance and that yes in terms of rewinding do you think we can why in the system back sort of the the nice thing about many-worlds I guess is it really emphasizes the maybe you can correct me but to determine it the deterministic nature of a branch and it feels like it could be a while back is it is do you see is this something that can be perfectly one that rewinded back yeah you know if you're at a fancy French restaurant yeah there's a nice linen white tablecloth and you have your glass of Bordeaux and you knock it over and the wine spills across the tablecloth if the world were classical okay it would be possible that if you just lifted the wine glass up you'd be lucky enough that every molecule of wine would hop back into the glass right but guess what it's not going to happen in the real world and the quantum wave function is exactly the same way it is possible in principle to rewind everything if you start from perfect knowledge of the entire wave function of the universe in practice that's never gonna happen so time travel not possible nope at least quantum mechanics has no help what about memory does the universe have a memory of itself or we could in in so not time travel but peek back in time and do a little like replay well it's exactly the same in quantum mechanics as classical mechanics so whatever you want to say about that you know the fundamental laws of physics in either many worlds quantum mechanics or Newtonian physics conserve information so if you have all the information about the quantum state of the world right now your Laplace's demon-like and your knowledge and calculational capacity you can wind the clock backward but none of us is right and you know so in practice you could never do that you can do experiments over and over again starting from the same initial conditions for small systems but once things get to be large Avogadro's number of particles right bigger than a cell no chance you